×
Mystic Pizza NYC Tickets
Venue: Paper Mill Playhouse
Get “Mystic Pizza” tickets at the Paper Mill Playhouse in Millburn, NY. These mesmerizing theatre shows will provide great memories for years. “Cheap Broadway Tickets” takes pride in providing guaranteed tickets at the best prices. The next event begins in:
--
Days
--
Hours
--
Minutes
--
Seconds
Contents
Schedule & Tickets
Mystic Pizza On Tour
Mystic Pizza Ticket Prices
Mystic Pizza
Upcoming Shows 2025
Upcoming Shows: 36
-
Jan2920257:30 PMWedPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $165Available Tickets: 185
-
Jan3020251:30 PMThuPrices from $118TicketsAvg. price ~ $374Available Tickets: 52
-
Jan3020257:30 PMThuPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $169Available Tickets: 160
-
Jan3120257:30 PMFriPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $187Available Tickets: 144
-
Feb0120251:30 PMSatPrices from $139TicketsAvg. price ~ $256Available Tickets: 66
-
Feb0120257:30 PMSatPrices from $118TicketsAvg. price ~ $247Available Tickets: 80
-
Feb0220251:30 PMSunPrices from $162TicketsAvg. price ~ $309Available Tickets: 51
-
Feb0220257:00 PMSunPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $27046 tickets remaining!
-
Feb0520257:30 PMWedPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $175Available Tickets: 142
-
Feb0620251:30 PMThuPrices from $118TicketsAvg. price ~ $39137 tickets remaining!
-
Feb0620257:30 PMThuPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $207Available Tickets: 96
-
Feb0720257:30 PMFriPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $188Available Tickets: 148
-
Feb0820251:30 PMSatPrices from $105TicketsAvg. price ~ $32445 tickets remaining!
-
Feb0820257:30 PMSatPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $238Available Tickets: 88
-
Feb0920251:30 PMSunPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $243Available Tickets: 87
-
Feb0920257:00 PMSunPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $184Available Tickets: 170
-
Feb1220257:30 PMWedPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $328Available Tickets: 201
-
Feb1320251:30 PMThuPrices from $117TicketsAvg. price ~ $327Available Tickets: 70
-
Feb1320257:30 PMThuPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $185Available Tickets: 161
-
Feb1420257:30 PMFriPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $183Available Tickets: 244
-
Feb1520251:30 PMSatPrices from $105TicketsAvg. price ~ $219Available Tickets: 117
-
Feb1520257:30 PMSatPrices from $73TicketsAvg. price ~ $190Available Tickets: 195
-
Feb1620251:30 PMSunPrices from $106TicketsAvg. price ~ $253Available Tickets: 86
-
Feb1620257:00 PMSunPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $193Available Tickets: 145
-
Feb1920257:30 PMWedPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $162Available Tickets: 280
-
Feb2020251:30 PMThuPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $240Available Tickets: 97
-
Feb2020257:30 PMThuPrices from $60TicketsAvg. price ~ $168Available Tickets: 236
-
Feb2120257:30 PMFriPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $383Available Tickets: 252
-
Feb2220251:30 PMSatPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $186Available Tickets: 213
-
Feb2220257:30 PMSatPrices from $74TicketsAvg. price ~ $179Available Tickets: 201
Show More
Mystic Pizza Ticket Prices
| Date | Venue | Min price | Max price | Avg. price | Available Tickets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Jan 29, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $427 | $165 | 185 |
|
Jan 30, 2025 Thu 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$118 | $491 | $374 | 52 |
|
Jan 30, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $427 | $169 | 160 |
|
Jan 31, 2025 Fri 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $427 | $187 | 144 |
|
Feb 01, 2025 Sat 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$139 | $482 | $256 | 66 |
|
Feb 01, 2025 Sat 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$118 | $482 | $247 | 80 |
|
Feb 02, 2025 Sun 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$162 | $482 | $309 | 51 |
|
Feb 02, 2025 Sun 7:00 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $482 | $270 | 46 |
|
Feb 05, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $427 | $175 | 142 |
|
Feb 06, 2025 Thu 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$118 | $482 | $391 | 37 |
|
Feb 06, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $482 | $207 | 96 |
|
Feb 07, 2025 Fri 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $500 | $188 | 148 |
|
Feb 08, 2025 Sat 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$105 | $500 | $324 | 45 |
|
Feb 08, 2025 Sat 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $500 | $238 | 88 |
|
Feb 09, 2025 Sun 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $500 | $243 | 87 |
|
Feb 09, 2025 Sun 7:00 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $500 | $184 | 170 |
|
Feb 12, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $5888 | $328 | 201 |
|
Feb 13, 2025 Thu 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$117 | $500 | $327 | 70 |
|
Feb 13, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $500 | $185 | 161 |
|
Feb 14, 2025 Fri 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $500 | $183 | 244 |
|
Feb 15, 2025 Sat 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$105 | $500 | $219 | 117 |
|
Feb 15, 2025 Sat 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$73 | $500 | $190 | 195 |
|
Feb 16, 2025 Sun 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$106 | $500 | $253 | 86 |
|
Feb 16, 2025 Sun 7:00 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $500 | $193 | 145 |
|
Feb 19, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $500 | $162 | 280 |
|
Feb 20, 2025 Thu 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $500 | $240 | 97 |
|
Feb 20, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $500 | $168 | 236 |
|
Feb 21, 2025 Fri 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $8379 | $383 | 252 |
|
Feb 22, 2025 Sat 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $500 | $186 | 213 |
|
Feb 22, 2025 Sat 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $427 | $179 | 201 |
|
Feb 23, 2025 Sun 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$74 | $500 | $193 | 171 |
|
Feb 23, 2025 Sun 7:00 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$60 | $427 | $157 | 248 |
|
Feb 26, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$117 | $500 | $404 | 40 |
|
Feb 27, 2025 Thu 1:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$117 | $500 | $404 | 40 |
|
Feb 27, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$117 | $500 | $404 | 40 |
|
Feb 28, 2025 Fri 7:30 PM |
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ |
$117 | $500 | $404 | 40 |
|
Jun 03, 2025 Tue 7:30 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$95 | $427 | $209 | 198 |
|
Jun 04, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$95 | $427 | $211 | 206 |
|
Jun 05, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$95 | $427 | $206 | 186 |
|
Jun 06, 2025 Fri 7:30 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$65 | $427 | $208 | 216 |
|
Jun 07, 2025 Sat 2:00 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$92 | $427 | $222 | 180 |
|
Jun 07, 2025 Sat 7:30 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$59 | $427 | $207 | 82 |
|
Jun 08, 2025 Sun 1:30 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$53 | $427 | $215 | 192 |
|
Jun 08, 2025 Sun 7:00 PM |
Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts, Saint Paul, MN |
$95 | $427 | $214 | 198 |
|
Jun 10, 2025 Tue 7:30 PM |
Pikes Peak Center, Colorado Springs, CO |
$57 | $473 | $202 | 26 |
|
Jun 11, 2025 Wed 7:30 PM |
Pikes Peak Center, Colorado Springs, CO |
$49 | $473 | $199 | 26 |
|
Jun 12, 2025 Thu 7:30 PM |
Pikes Peak Center, Colorado Springs, CO |
$41 | $509 | $255 | 27 |
|
Jun 14, 2025 Sat 2:00 PM |
Lied Center For Performing Arts, Lincoln, NE |
$391 | $527 | $513 | 18 |
|
Jun 14, 2025 Sat 7:30 PM |
Lied Center For Performing Arts, Lincoln, NE |
$391 | $509 | $513 | 18 |
|
Jun 15, 2025 Sun 1:30 PM |
Lied Center For Performing Arts, Lincoln, NE |
$391 | $546 | $526 | 20 |
All Shows in NYC
Disney On Ice: Frozen & Encanto
Upcoming Events: 4
Barclays Center
Jan 18, 2025 7:00 PM 
Harry Potter and The Cursed Child
Upcoming Events: 299
Lyric Theatre - New York
Jan 18, 2025 7:00 PM 
Disney On Ice
Upcoming Events: 4
BMO Harris Bank Center
Jan 18, 2025 7:00 PM 
The Lion King
Upcoming Events: 169
Minskoff Theatre
Jan 18, 2025 8:00 PM 
Wicked
Upcoming Events: 330
Gershwin Theatre
Jan 18, 2025 8:00 PM 
Hell's Kitchen - The Musical
Upcoming Events: 332
Shubert Theatre - NY
Jan 18, 2025 8:00 PM 
The Outsiders
Upcoming Events: 195
Bernard B. Jacobs Theater
Jan 18, 2025 8:00 PM 
Ira Glass
Upcoming Events: 2
Tarrytown Music Hall
Jan 18, 2025 8:00 PM 
Sunset Boulevard
Upcoming Events: 195
St. James Theatre
Jan 18, 2025 8:00 PM 
Oh, Mary!
Upcoming Events: 186
Lyceum Theatre - New York
Jan 18, 2025 8:30 PM 
Titanique - Musical
Upcoming Events: 266
Daryl Roth Theatre
Jan 18, 2025 9:00 PM 
Pinkalicious
Upcoming Events: 20
Actors Temple Theater
Jan 19, 2025 11:00 AM 
Blue Man Group
Upcoming Events: 18
Astor Place Theatre
Jan 19, 2025 12:00 PM 
The Gazillion Bubble Show
Upcoming Events: 133
New World Stages: Stage 2
Jan 19, 2025 12:00 PM 
Aladdin
Upcoming Events: 170
New Amsterdam Theatre
Jan 19, 2025 1:00 PM 
Hamilton
Upcoming Events: 167
Belk Theatre at Blumenthal Performing Arts Center
Jan 19, 2025 1:00 PM 
MJ - The Musical
Upcoming Events: 313
Academy Of Music - PA
Jan 19, 2025 1:00 PM 
& Juliet - Musical
Upcoming Events: 188
Stephen Sondheim Theatre
Jan 19, 2025 1:00 PM 
Moulin Rouge - The Musical
Upcoming Events: 187
Al Hirschfeld Theatre
Jan 19, 2025 1:30 PM 
The Great Gatsby - Theatrical Production
Upcoming Events: 266
Broadway Theatre - New York
Jan 19, 2025 2:00 PM
Show More